Log in

No account? Create an account
TWIB-III: 13  
03:36am 12/01/2009
Discard Before Using
I read twelve books this week. Only two were in English. So I think I'm going to start including (some but not all) of the Japanese books I've read in these writeups alongside their English-language brethren. Who knows? Someone might even decide to translate them some day.

1) 日米関係史 - 五百旗頭 真(編)
    A History of U.S.-Japan Relations - Iokibe Makoto (ed.)

This book, which was published in mid-2008, is the most up-to-date examination of U.S.-Japan relations of which I'm currently aware. It offers a nuanced, balanced examination of the history of these two Pacific powers from the early 18th century to the present day.

日米関係史's greatest strength lies in the decision of its authors not to examine U.S.-Japan relations through a predefined framework (a la LaFeber's Clash); this allows them to respond to individual events instead of attempting to shoehorn them into some larger relational paradigm. Despite the fact that all but one of the contributors are Japanese, the text is relatively objective. That said, the tone does get much more subjective and selective from the 1980's onward; its discussions of trade friction are rather pro-Japan and the final chapter on the Bush II-era is little more than a brief chronology of relevant events with little interpretation or explanation of the policy debates that shaped bilateral relations in the wake of 9/11. Still, one could do a lot, lot worse than this volume; I'd recommend it to any Japanese-speakers looking for comprehensive but relatively in-depth examination of the U.S.-Japan relationship.

2) Alignment Despite Antagonism - Victor Cha
Cha's book starts with an interesting question--why does Realism fail to explain the acrimony present in Japan-ROK relations--and offers an interesting solution--that the degree of cooperation between these two nations is a function of each country's interpretation of U.S. actions in the region.

On a basic level, Cha's observation is a sound one: when both states fear a lessening of the U.S. security presence in Northeast Asia they are more likely to put aside their differences in order to protect against common regional security threats. Conversely, when both Japan and the ROK feel confident in a continuing U.S. military presence, they feel they have the leeway to engage in disputes over military, economic, and political matters.

That Japan and South Korea would feel compelled to seek new (albeit less desirable) allies in the wake of weakening U.S. commitment is common sense. But it's hard to take the argument beyond that, because despite Cha's protestations to the contrary, historical animosity, domestic factors, and the persuasion of individual politicians do exert influence over their conduct of foreign policy. More broadly, Cha's argument founders on two main, interrelated flaws: Cha's attachment to his pet theory and the impossibility of quantifying the ratio of friction to cooperation within the Japan-ROK relationship. In other words, the lack of an objective means to measure friction or cooperation allows Cha to emphasize whichever element best suits his argument even in the face of alternate explanations for state behavior. He also contradicts his own interpretations of historical events (e.g. the Carter administration's ultimate decision not to redeploy from South Korea either did or did not reassure its allies, depending on the exigencies of Cha's argument) and makes illogical statements (e.g. Kim Dae-jung was arrested on trumped-up charges of instigating riots in Kwangju that were actually the result of his arrest--a chronological impossibility).

It's hard to tell whether this is more the result of shoddy editing (which is evident throughout--parenthesis are frequently left unclosed, and Japanese words are misspelled) or a function of Cha's inability to consider aspects of the historical record that disprove his thesis, but I rather suspect the latter. Furthermore, this book was published in 1999; the latest date in the text itself is, I believe 1997, and I think it says something that Cha has not revisted this theory since them. (Indeed, I would be interested to hear Cha's interpretation of how the Sunshine Policy, friction over the DPRK hostage crisis, and the Six Party talks (among other developments) fit this theory.)

End verdict: while this book is worth reading for students of Northeast Asian relations, that worth lies more in the opportunity to question Cha's thesis than it does in the thesis itself.

3) This is Paradise! - Hyok Kang
This short but compelling book is the story of its author's childhood in Onsong, a city in northern North Korea. In it, Kang narrates his memories of early childhood: attending school, laboring in the fields and mines, witnessing executions, the life-or-death struggle to survive the 1995 famine, and his defection to China and finally South Korea.

First the bad: this story was related to a French journalist via an interpreter and Kang and journalist's limited Chinese skills, before being translated into English from the French. Thus there's a lot of noise introduced into the text; it does not read like Korean to my ears. Furthermore, the English translator does not seem to be familiar with Korean; his transliteratons of Korean words resemble no romanisation system I've ever seen. If anything, they look like bastardized pinyin.

And now the good: Kang's tale is riveting, and as Kang is the youngest defector (of whom I'm aware) to have written a memoir, both his outlook and the events he describes frequently differ from those found in other memoirs. I feel I've come a bit closer to understanding how the North Korean regime has maintained the allegiance of its citizens for having read this volume. Indeed, it makes Kang's narrative of thievery, cannibalism, and brutal fights for survival all the more heartbreaking. I only wish Kang had been more able to describe his defection (through China, Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia), although I understand why this was clearly impossible. Final verdict: it is well worth your time to read this book

That will be all.
location: ze rectangle
music: simian mobile disco - tits and acid
tags: books, reading
    Mr. Howe! - 4 Pilotless drones - - Link

(no subject)
02:40pm 12/01/2009 (UTC)
You never fail to impress me. That you could read 12 books in one week when they are actually academic difficult tomes, not plithy novels and such (nothing wrong with novels but they do read faster), and then in Japanese no less...I can't even begin to comprehend. I have no choice but to realize that I'm really not nearly as fluent in Japanese as I like to think I am!!

But I thoroughly thoroughly approve of the inclusion of Japanese books on here. Please please do. I've actually been wishing you would for a while.
Especially since I know sometimes you do read novels, and I need some new authors to check out sometimes. I only really read the really famous names in Japanese lit - Murakami Ryu, Haruki, Banana, Takemoto Novala (not like the rest but still a pretty obvious choice for me), Yoshiya Nobuko (need more of this still though...oh well I'll still include her), and I've read some Yoshi and other keitai novels influenced by my students, which was good for laughs but that's about it. I think that's all I've ever read in Japanese, so it would be nice to know some other awesome novelists.

That third one sounds very intriguing.
    Mr. Howe! - Thread - span>Link
(no subject)
02:56am 15/01/2009 (UTC)
Discard Before Using: ajk
Aww, thanks! But you really are giving me too much credit. Most the other nine volumes were shosetsu (and a fair amount of trashy ladies/bl shosetsu at that!), which is why I did not talk about them^^

If you're looking for some other authors to check out, Ekuni Kaori is quite similar to Banana, but I really like her books and especially her short stories. I recommend 「流しのしたの骨」and「きらきらひかる]

梨本果歩's「西の魔女が死んだ」is a really sweet and moving slice-of-life book that I read about a year ago. It's blown up pretty big since then; there's a movie I'm hoping to check out one of these days.

夢枕 獏's Onmyoji novels are really interesting reading but can be kinda heavy, what with all the Heian and magical terminology. For lighter historical reads, I really like 畠中恵's books, which are supernatural mysteries set in the Edo era.

I've written up some other authors in the past; I'll see if I can dig up links for ya. And I really do recommend checking out the Kang memoir--you can easily read it in the space of a few hours and it's worth every minute.
picword: ajk
    Mr. Howe! - Parent - span>Thread - span>Link
(no subject)
06:04pm 12/01/2009 (UTC)
Count me in with the impressed. When I read about you and things you've done it never fails to motivate me, especially academically. The other day when you talked about the prof that had taught at Harvard for 20 years giving you an A, I couldn't really understand why you were surprised. You do realize that there aren't a lot of people with the ability that you have, right?

I'd also like to see more reviews of Japanese books, when possible. I actually haven't managed to read my first novel in Japanese yet, but am pretty close to making the attempt. I'm either going to Start with キッチン or the first Harry Potter novel, translated.
    Mr. Howe! - Thread - span>Link
(no subject)
03:01am 15/01/2009 (UTC)
Discard Before Using: ajk
Thank you:-) But it really did come as a surprise.

I've never read the HP novels in Japanese, but I had a friend who did and said it helped his novel-reading considerably. The first book I read in Japanese just happens to be キッチン, so I'm a fan of going that route. The first couple of pages were tough until I got used to the novel format, but then I got sucked into the story and it flew by. In fact, it might be better to go with キッチン. All the accents and magical terminology in HP might actually make it harder to read in Japanese, as that sort of stuff doesn't usually appear in dictionaries.

Anyway, I recced some of my other favorites in the post above this one, so do check those out if you're feeling inclined^^
picword: ajk
    Mr. Howe! - Parent - span>Thread - span>Link

  Previous Entry
Next Entry
July 2014  

  Powered by